Red Dead Redemption
Completionist Info


Episode Number 40
Date Released October 25th, 2012
Completionist Rating Have Fun and Finish It!
Link Red Dead Redemption
Super Beard Bros. Info
Red Dead Redemption 1 - High Noon

Red Dead Redemption 1 - High Noon

Series Number 46
Date Began December 1st, 2016
Date Ended August 29th, 2017
Number of Episodes 34 + Bonus
Playlist Super Cowboy Bros.

Red Dead Redemption is an open world western action-adventure video game developed by Rockstar San Diego and published by Rockstar Games. It was released for the PlayStation 3 and Xbox 360 consoles on May 18, 2010. It is the second title in the Red Dead franchise, and is a spiritual successor to 2004's Red Dead Revolver. The game, set during the decline of the American Frontier in the year 1911, follows John Marston, a former outlaw whose wife and son are taken hostage by the government in ransom for his services as a bounty hunter. Having no other choice, Marston sets out to bring the three members of his former gang to justice.

Red Dead Redemption is played from a third-person perspective in an open world environment, allowing the player to interact with the game world at their leisure. The player can travel the virtual world, a fictionalized version of the Western United States and Mexico, primarily by horseback and on foot. Gunfights emphasize a gunslinger gameplay mechanic called "Dead Eye" that allows players to mark multiple shooting targets on enemies in slow motion. The game makes use of a morality system, by which the player's actions in the game affect their character's levels of honor and fame and how other characters respond to the player. An online multiplayer mode is included with the game, allowing up to 16 players to engage in both cooperative and competitive gameplay in a recreation of the single-player setting.

This page uses Creative Commons Licensed content from Wikipedia (view authors).

The CompletionistEdit

Uploaded on October 25th, 2012, Greg reviewed Red Dead Redemption for the third episode of The Mediocre-ist. It also serves as the pre-finale of the first season of The Completionist. As with other Mediocre-ist episodes, Greg takes over the show and leads whilst Jirard fills in Greg's role as the funnyman.

Jirard is extremely pessimistic of Greg's ability to complete the game. However, Greg's very optimistic, due to his love for the game. Surprisingly, Greg does a much better job at detailing aspects of this game compared to other reviews he's done.

Greg praises the story for its use of Western themes in a Grand Theft Auto-type game, but does have some gripes with the pacing of the story early on. However, he praises the open world aspect, presentation, and variety. Jirard interjects his opinion briefly to express gripes with cattle herding.

Greg gives props to the control scheme, as well as the visual representation of taking damage without a health bar. He also appreciates the choice of guns, and duels. Special attention is also given to the "Dead Eye" system, which allows for pinpoint accuracy when shooting. He also likes the "Undead Nightmare" DLC that changes up the game significantly.

Since this is the first game Greg ever completed, this sends Jirard into a shock, turning him into the Comportionist and Greg becoming the Completionist by default.


  • This is one of the few games Greg is ever credited to being good at and has completed himself.
  • This is the first episode that sets up a Completionist finale. 
  • This is the only episode that doesn't reveal the final level / ending 

Super Beard Bros.Edit

Alex has never been more excited to play any game in the history of the show. He and Jirard had planned on playing Red Dead Redemption for some time but never had the balls to dot it. But since they finished L.A. Noire they thought 'let's do it'. Jirard had played it before, and according to Alex, is very good at it. Played on XBOX One.

Episodes Edit

  1. High Noon
  2. Stagecoach
  3. Open Range
  4. The Searchers
  5. The Shootist
  6. The Big Trail
  7. Phantom Rancher
  8. Branded
  9. At Gunpoint
  10. The Big Country
  11. An Accidental Outlaw
  12. Winning of the West
  13. Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
  15. All the Pretty Horses
  16. Far and Away
  17. Hang'em High
  18. Pale Rider
  19. Once Upon A Time In The West
  20. The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
  21. Fist Full of Dollars
  22. El Diablo
  23. Comin' at Ya!
  24. Blazing Saddles
  25. Django Unchained
  26. 1000 Ways to Die in the West
  27. The Ridiculous Six
  28. The Magnificent Seven
  29. West World
  30. Best Western
  31. Underneath High
  32. Grit Pit McGrit
  33. McCree and Co.
  34. It All Ends With a Bang
  35. Bonus - No Name on the Bullet
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.